Home > Personal injury attorney in Orange Park, FL > Accident Lawyer John Fagan Review

Accident Lawyer John Fagan

Personal injury attorney in Orange Park, FL
Reviews: 45 | Overal Rating: Good
Excellect
37
Good
3
Average
2
Bad
0
Awful
3
Wednesday Open 24 hours
Thursday Open 24 hours
Friday Open 24 hours
Saturday Open 24 hours
Sunday Open 24 hours
Monday Open 24 hours
Tuesday Open 24 hours

Reviews

Review Left On 02/26/2020
Gary Mace

Daphne and Adrienne have been very informative . They helped me get the medical treatment I needed after the accident. For an experience I’ve never been through before, I highly recommend this team.
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Kathryn McQueen

Daphne and the staff at John Fagan provided and demonstrated professional service in each of my cases. Daphne was available to answer every medical, insurance, and any additional legal question of my concern. Daphne consistently contacted me when there was an update in my case. I had no worries or stress on the outcome of my case. I would highly recommend Daphne!
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Lisa Mari

I was hurt on my job and I’m very happy that John answered my phone call and that I used his service. My attorney David and Assistant Debbie were fantastic! Everybody in the office completely courteous too, if it wasn’t for them, I wouldn’t of gotten such a good settlement. Anybody going to Workers Comp needs ATTORNEY’s like this firm.
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Paul Wheat

Over all it was not bad.. dealing with work comp I found that very few are on your side and no matter who you are, you are now viewed as a lazy criminal. Debbie was great and communication was clear. Dave did his job but nothing more. I do not feel I was prepared for what I heard in mediation to the extent of the numbers.. as an office 4 stars.. Debbie... 5 stars... the experience... well I'm sorry anyone is even looking for an attorney for help.
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Dawn Battle

Had a wonderful experience at The Fagan Law Firm! Mr. Daze was wonderful to work with, full of wisdom and helped me get my settlement quickly. Would use this law firm again!
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Janice Morris

Excellent!!!!!Staff there are very kind and helpful!!!!!Keep up the good work guys!!!!!
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Maria Galarza

My experience was not very pleasant, first we were new clients without any experience about car accidents for that reason we did not know how the process will be or how long that could last. When we started the process we never got explained step by step how will work. We expected more communication from the person in charge of the case in our case was Adrianne, She never answered a call and when I sent emails I did not get an answer on time, most of the time it took more than 48 hours for her to respond and I was not pleased with the answer of my question (leaving me with doubts about what I was asking) when the case of property damage part was finally over with her, the case goes on demand for the insurer which never I saw some copy but I have to clarify that Mrs Daphne nail was very kind.
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Kristen R.

First off, if I could give Daphne ZERO stars, I would. She was terrible with communication! She could never accept a phone call, I always had to leave messages that she never returned, and didn't even call me on SCHEDULED conference calls.

The three stars is only because of my beginning experiences.....

My case was transferred to Adrienne, if you have a case here, REQUEST HER. She was such a breath of fresh air. She kept me updated via email about everything. I understand that a lot of phone tag happens during these cases, but she kept me updated on everything. Not a week went by that she didn't tell me what was going on. She fought very hard for me to get my bills and med pay down so that my settlement was better. In the end, she turned an awful experience into a good one. She definitely deserves 5 stars!!

Thanks!
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Chaos with the Christopher's

I don't reccomend this attorney at all. They drug my case out for 6 years. I went 8m without them contacting me. They aren't genuinely for you. I was told that my case wasn't putting any money in their pockets. That's when I knew I had to fire them. 6 years too long! I reccomend Byrd & Byrd!
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Kim Neast

I did not have a good experience with this firm. I retained Mr. Fagan for a serious car accident where I was injured and my car was totaled. I was not at fault and even though Florida is a no fault state, I thought it would be in my best interest to have Mr. Fagan handle the issues. I met with his investigator, who although is very nice, he did not investigate anything. No witnesses were contacted and nothing was done other than the generic JSO report. You see nothing was done because Mr. Fagan’s office took six weeks to verify coverage of the at fault driver. I do not blame the office for this, however the timeliness of getting the letter out and following up was not great. The other side has thirty days to respond. Once we find out that the at fault driver had the bare minimum coverage, there was really nothing for Mr. Fagans office to do as there was no big bucks involved. The other policy didn’t even cover the loss of my car. Again, no fault state, Florida’s crappy insurance laws. Everything had to shift back to my UM policy. I attempted to wrap of the claim when our treatment ended months ago and kept getting told they needed more records and was still requesting docs.... now here is my biggest issue and I will just use the past two weeks as an example. I was told on 6/14 that my demand was being worked on and that she was going to try to get in touch with my doctor and call me back by the end of business day Friday 6/15 in how we would proceed. 6/15 came and went with no call back, I called on Monday 6/18, she called me back with an excuse and said she could not get a conference with my doctor for over a month out and stated she thought now the demand was sufficient and she would have it sent out by Friday 6/22. I asked her why she had changed her mind about needing to clarify with the doctor and now she was ready to proceed and she explained due to the time to schedule and she did not feel it would change the claim after reviewing additional docs. I asked that a copy of the demand be sent to me when it was sent out for 6/22. 6/22 came and went and no demand in my email or confirmation that it was sent out. Emailed on Monday morning stating I had overdue expenses and I was told it would go out by the end of that day. Again, I asked for a copy and confirmation it went out. I sent an email inquiry at 445 with no response. I called my adjuster at 530 who advised they had not received anything from Mr. Fagans office to settle the claim. I sent an email to both Amanda and Daphne advising them that since they were not meeting the deadlines they offered up to me, to please send a letter to my adjuster withdrawing from the claim, so I can just settle it myself. Mind you my case sat stagnant for two months, while I was pushing to wrap things up. Here’s the deal, Mr. Fagans office did nothing for me that I couldn’t do myself. All that was happening here was in order for Fagans office to get paid, they had to go against my policy. Okay makes sense, however if my PIP was already exhausted and I still had bills, I was essentially not going to pay all my bills to give his office their required payment. So there was no investigation, no sueing the at fault driver, and the other insurance company doesn’t have to pay out more than their policy covers... again if it didn’t take so long to verify coverages at the beginning, I would not have retained his office. When we found out about the coverage issue for the at fault driver, I advised both Amanda and Mr. Fagan that I wanted to sue the at fault driver directly and make him responsible financially. I did not want to go after my own policy just to pay attorney fees & then likely get dropped from my carrier. Fagans office was not interested in pursuing liability against the at fault driver. I did my own research and discovered the driver was not married & had no full time dependents, which meant he could be sued and his wages garnished. Fagan’s office was not interested because not enough $$$ in that legal process, but told me I could do it myself. Well that’s what I hired you for...
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Jov M

Great services!
Review Left On 02/26/2020
Tracey Lawler

My experience with this firm was not only better than I anticipated, it was a huge relief. I didn't have to babysit like I did with the large firm I left to come here. Attorney, David Drill was professional, knowledgeable, understanding and straightforward. He was never dismissive or intolerant of my tears and always asked me for my input while offering his perspective and expertise. The office staff was always friendly and responsive. I will be referring literally everyone I can here. I can’t thank them enough.
Review Left On 02/05/2020
District 14

I was very pleased with the service I received at John Fagan. My representative David Drill was top notch in getting my case out in the open and getting the settlement done. Mrs.Debbie his assistant was wonderful, she kept me in the loop with all the needed appointment and any other information I desired. I would say to anyone considering an attorney to call John Fagan.
Review Left On 11/26/2019
Marianna Midyette

Great firm was very Happy with adraine with the out come with my case
Review Left On 11/26/2019
Paul Maynard

They were very helpful in my case I recommend them highly
Review Left On 06/26/2019
Hope Webb

Terrible , I have been trying to get ahold of them for 2 years now , to find out the status of my son's case , they haven't yet return my call .
I wouldn't use him again if my life depended on it.
Review Left On 06/26/2019
Renée Darnell

I have recommended Accident Lawyer John Fagan to my family and friends.

The Team at Accident Lawyer John Fagan has done an outstanding job representing them.
Review Left On 04/26/2019
Wesley Caton

My experience has been nothing but amazing, Daphne has been astounding and no matter what obscure demand was made by me or insurance she rolled with punches. Her transparancy really meant a lot to me, she was straight forward with every step we were in.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
matt Fronczak

Very highly recommended! Great people there, treat you like family. Daphne was very helpful and reliable I would advise anyone to give them a call if you need an attorney! They won’t stir you wrong.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Dennis Stark

Great Lawyers
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Rand Peterson

John Fagan did an exceptional job in dealing with my accident claim. Daphne was also a key player in the settlement that I received. I would definitely use John Fagan (and Daphne) again if the need would ever arise in the future.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Michael Gambino

Amazing service great team and very helpful in every way possible
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Melissa Daughtry

My fiancee was hit by 18 wheeler truck and he has been suffering for so long and has been going through a lot and surgeries. He is almost towards the end of this ordeal but his pain is none stop. But Mr. John Fagan and his outstanding case manager Daphne Nail has been so great. We have a large settlement comimg and this will help to stabilize his life financially. But the health recovery will be long. I thank John Fagan attorney for all the hard work theyve done upto this point.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Emily Stroup

Very helpful and very knowledgeable.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Christine Stroup

I have nothing but good things to say about John and his team!
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Casey Stroup

John is doing a wonderful job for a good friend of mine that was recently in an accident. I would definitely recommend him and his team!
Review Left On 02/26/2018
andrew sellers

John Fagan and his staff have been very professional with my special circumstance. Daphne and AJ in particular went above and beyond to help me through my event. They also assisted in matters unrelated to my case that were very beneficial for me. I highly recommend the law office of John Fagan....and ask for Daphne
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Joan Brackin

The challenges that my daughter has experienced since her car accident last summer have been many. This law firm and their supportive staff have always had an open ear and were only a phone call or email away to answer questions regarding getting her the medical help that she has needed. I highly recommend this group of people to be there in your time of need.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Alicia Williams

I highly recommend John Fagan for your personal injury lawyer. The staff is very professional and knowledgeable. They are always a phone call away ready to address any of your cares and concerns. When you first meet with John Fagan he makes you feel comfortable and confident he will do the best job he can for you.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Rick Bartley

So far top notch group of staff. From account manager's that are on top of it and get answers quick to John Fagan being available when needed. Couldn't ask for a better law firm to represent my case.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Lady Jones

Superb team. Customer satisfaction seems to be high on the priority list. If you're looking for a professional committed to doing what's best for you John Fagan is highly recommended.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Cedrica Morgan

I have had nothing but a positive experience with this law firm. They are very attentive to my specific case and needs and are always checking in with me to make sure that I am ok
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Janice Eckholm

They were very through in handling my case. They explained the ins and outs of being hit by a vehicle.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Markehan Littles

John Fagan and his staff have been wonderful to me. They are constantly in contact with me and checking to see how I am doing, how everything is going, and if there is anything they can do to help my process. Thank you John and also to your team for everything.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Tanesia Clark

Excellent
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Coley Bagocius

Wonderful people. Taking care of us in our time of need......
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Danny Watts

I've never read a negative review about John Fagan, so I can be confident that they believe in customer satisfaction. I'm sure I will never need to worry about inconsistencies.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Thomas Carter

Fanastic Firm, couldn't ask for better service when my family needed it! They provided well for my family. I would reccommend this firm to anyone who needs a lawyer!
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Sandra Danner

I really wish I had called John Fagan firm to be on my side a couple years ago after an accident. I did not hire any representation and have always felt like the insurance company cheated me from a fair settlement. It was a time I needed to feel like I had family on my side and everyone at this law firm will treat you like family. John is an especially amazing community advocate. Don't make the mistake I did! Call John Fagan law firm today!
Review Left On 02/26/2018
George Clay

Phenomenal Group!! They truly and sincerely ou feel like family. I felt peace from the moment I walked into the door. They are a hard working group that not only contacted me any and every time they had information, but they also were always quick to chemake yck on me and my family. They have really blown my mind with just how much they genuinely care. You will not be just another case to them, you will be family.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
BoJaKai

This firm is reliable and will work hard for you while making you feel important! Don't hesitate to give Joe Fagan a try. You WILL NOT be disappointed!
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Jose Hernandez

John Fagan is a great attorney, he will fight hard against the insurance companies and get you the highest amount for your settlement. I highly recommed this law firm.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
EC dafee

A great Law firm that really cares about people and will fight to get you a good settlement on any injury case.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Matthew Brunetto

I was involved in a motor vehicle accident coming home from work. I was on my motorcycle and I had an 18 year old do a u-turn in front of me and slam on her brakes causing me to lay my bike down. I called John Fagan the day after the accident and with in 9 months everything was settled. I would recommend Fagan to anyone and would use him again I was involved in another accident.
Review Left On 02/26/2018
Danny Crawford

John Fagan is very professional. I never had to worry about anything.
I would highly recommend him to anyone i know! The people at his firm are very trustworthy and they always do what they say there going to do.
Its been a long experience but was well worth it!

Leave A Review For For Accident Lawyer John Fagan


Useful Links